What’s going on?
Describe it in your own words. Free to ask, no billable hours, and a licensed Arizona attorney reviews every matter.
MEET BLUESHOE
Justice is leverage, not luxury. Smart. On-demand. For everyone.
Blueshoe connects you with a dedicated attorney for your legal matter. No billable hours. No gatekeepers. No nonsense.
ASSESS
Fast to start, aligned to the finish
We never bill by the hour. Our only incentive is the best outcome for you, as fast as possible. Bring any question or concern, and you get streamlined intake and assessment, quick turnaround, and transparent pricing. We break out the exact costs, if any, at every stage, so you always know what to expect.
BUILD
Service that leaves no stone unturned
Our legal intelligence keeps your entire matter in context. Every document, message, and decision. Purpose-built workflows find missing information, review, monitor and fix issues proactively, sending you regular progress updates so you stay informed without worrying about checking in.
RETAIN
Trusted attorneys, professional expertise
We ensure every matter is driven by seasoned attorneys with expertise in the relevant area of law, providing the human judgment, strategy, and craft that you deserve. Technology speeds the groundwork, but human professionals make the decisions on your matter.
THE NETWORK
A network of premier trial attorneys.
Real attorneys, real results. A licensed Arizona attorney reviews every Blueshoe matter, and cases that belong in a courtroom go to lawyers who try cases for a living.
Catherine O’Grady
Managing Partner, Blueshoe Legal Services PLLC
The attorney who reviews every matter Blueshoe takes on. A Ninth Circuit clerk, Phoenix litigator, and 25-year law professor at ASU and the University of Arizona, she co-wrote the Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics article on AI agents as ethics counsel, then helped build the firm that runs on them.
- Employment
- Consumer protection
- Professional responsibility
- State Bar of Arizona No. 011647
- Clerk, U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
- Former Associate Dean, University of Arizona Law
Martin H. Mathers
Founder and Trial Lawyer, Gage Mathers
The lawyer other lawyers call when a catastrophic case gets complicated. Three decades of trial work against hospital systems, trucking companies, and Fortune 500 defendants, and ten years on the bench as a Judge Pro Tempore.
- Catastrophic injury
- Wrongful death
- Medical negligence
- Trucking
- Certified Specialist, Personal Injury and Wrongful Death
- Million Dollar Advocates Forum
- AV Preeminent, Martindale-Hubbell
Joseph D’Aguanno
Managing Attorney and Trial Lawyer, Gage Mathers
A math and molecular biology major who became one of Arizona’s most sought-after medical malpractice trial lawyers. His verdicts have made the state’s Top Ten list, and other malpractice lawyers ask him for advice.
- Medical malpractice
- Catastrophic injury
- Motor vehicle
- 2025 Southwest Super Lawyers, Personal Injury
- Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum
- Arizona Top Ten Trial Verdicts
Matthew R. Story
Trial Attorney, Gage Mathers
Started at the firm as a paralegal, helped work tens of millions in recoveries, then came back from ASU Law with an Order of Barristers pin. Takes the cases other firms decline.
- Motor vehicle accidents
- Dog bites
- Wrongful death
- Order of Barristers, ASU Law
- Admitted in Arizona, Colorado, and New Mexico
- 2023 Oplinger-Blake Opening Argument winner
Gage Mathers Law Group is an independent Arizona law firm. Attorneys outside Blueshoe Legal Services PLLC handle matters under co-counsel or referral arrangements disclosed to the client in writing.
Who we serve
Law for real people, not corner offices
Employment
Wrongful termination, discrimination, severance.
Medical & Injury
Malpractice, personal injury, insurance disputes.
Consumer & Financial
Debt collection, credit disputes, fraud, consumer protection.
Property & Construction
Purchases, closings, construction contracts, permits, disputes.
Product & Environment
Defective products, toxic exposure, and environmental contamination.
Creators & Founders
Brand deals, licensing, trademarks, IP, and the foundation to build on.
FOR ATTORNEYS
Great attorneys do their best work with us
“Blueshoe is a complete partner in the coming wave of generative AI and its impact on law. I get clients I can help. Back office support. I focus more on outcomes, and I get better results.”
Gage Mathers has a strong reputation as an aggressive, high-quality litigation law firm. Its team routinely appears on Arizona’s Top 10 verdicts list.
Our vision
Law is arguably the most consequential of professions in society. Attorneys carry deep expertise and real judgment into the practice, where a single outcome can alter someone’s livelihood, their family, their future. But the legal system in which they operate was never designed to serve most of the people who need them.
AI fundamentally reshapes the economics of justice. It absorbs much of the operational burden that consumes a lawyer’s day: the drafting, the review, the coordination, the follow-ups. It lets attorneys practice at a scale and a quality that the traditional model never permitted.
We’re not building another tool for law firms. We’re building the firm itself: one where every efficiency gain makes counsel more accessible, not more profitable for the people who already have it. And we’re doing it with attorneys who are ready to practice the way they always wanted to.
Casey O’Grady, CEO
Bank-level security comes standard for everyone.
Blueshoe holds the same security standards trusted by hospitals and financial institutions. Most consumer law firms don’t come close to this. We think that’s exactly backwards: The more personal the matter, the higher the bar should be.
SOC II Compliant
Our system meets the same security standards trusted by financial institutions.
HIPAA Compliant
Legal matters often involve sensitive health information. We protect it at the highest standard.
Independent Testing
Third-party security teams regularly test our systems so you don’t have to take our word for it.